Hello Class!
Please click on the 'comments' tab below to submit your answers to the SBQ (Chapter 8).
When you post your answers, PLEASE FOLLOW THE FORMAT BELOW:
Class:
Group Number:
Group Members' Names:
Question:
Answer:
Thanks and look forward to all your posts by the Deadline: Saturday, 16 July, 4pm :)
Class: 2 Diligence
ReplyDeleteGroup Number:3
Group Members' Names:
Samantha Yip (40)
Kathleen Wong (36)
Annabel Er (3)
Jessie Low (18)
Alicia Chew (1)
Ho Jing En (11)
Soh Yun Man (28)
Question: How is Source A similar to Source B?
(provide similarity in topic and one similarity in content)
Answer: Both sources are similar because they talk about Lim Yew Hoc'sk government.
Both sources state that Lim Yew Hock thought about the interest of the country. This is seen from Source A which states that "Lim was prepared to work with the British to achieve his constitutional goal" and Source B that says "under Lim Yew Hock we accepted policies which were right for Singapore."
Class: 2 Diligence
ReplyDeleteGroup Number:6
Group Members' Names:
Christine Saw (6)
Jamie Lee (13)
Jasmine Lim (16)
Rebecca Seah (26)
Tan Hui Min (29)
Audrey Tan (11)
Question: How is Source A different from Source B? (Provide difference in provenance and one different in content)
Answer:Source A is a view by an academic of Lim Yew Hock's government while Source B is a view by a fellow Party member of Lim Yew Hock's government.
The source are different because they provide conflicting perspectives on the success of Lim Yew Hock's government. Source A shows the Lim Yew Hock's government was not very successful as it ironically undermined the credibility of the Lim government which was perceived by the Chinese as the 'running dogs' of the British. However, source B tells us that the Lim Yew Hock's government was successful because under the Lim Yew Hock's government, Singapore 'accepted policies which were right for Singapore', such as 'giving everyone the opportunity to take citizenship' and 'compulsory voting'.
Class: 2 Diligence
ReplyDeleteGroup Number: 1
Group Members' Names:
Celine Goh (05)
Chuah Qing Le (07)
Liu Lin (17)
Natasha Lim (19)
Neo Yu Shan (20)
Theresa Phua (22)
Tang Ke Xin (33)
Question:
How similar are the 2 sources?
Answer:
Both sources are similar because they are about the Lim Yew Hock Government.
Both sources agree that Lim Yew Hock’s way of governing was different from David Marshall. This can be seen from Source A which states that ‘unlike Marshall, Lim was prepared to work with the British’, while Source B states that Lim Yew Hock accepted policies which ‘were wrong for the personal interests’ of the Labour front leadership, but which benefited Singapore.
However, both sources are different from each other because they provide conflicting views on the success of Lim Yew Hock’s government. This is seen from the Source A where the ‘Lim’ government ‘was perceived by the Chinese as the “running dogs” of the British while Source B states that the locals ‘accepted policies which were right for Singapore’ under Lim Yew Hock’s governing.
Class:2 Hope
ReplyDeleteGroup Number:6
Group Members' Names:Sarah Tan, Natalie Aw, Brenda Tan Leanne Chan, Amayniah Tan
Question:How is Source A different from Source B? (Provide difference in provenance and one different in content)
Answer:Source A is a view by an academic of Lim Yew Hock's government.The sources are different as they provide conflicting views on Lim Yew Hock's government. Source A shows that the government had no rights as seen in "perceived by the Chinese as the "running dogs" of the British" but source B states that the Lim Yew Hock government had rights and this is evident in "accepted policies which were right for Singapore".
class:2 Dilligence
ReplyDeletegroup number: 5
Group members: Xu Yanling, Tan Wei Xin, Bonnita Leman, Tania Tan, Clair Quek, Cristelle Ben
Question: How is Source A different from Source B?
Answer:
Source A is a view by an academic of Lim Yew Hock's government but source B is a view by a fellow party memeber of Lim Yew Hock's government.
The sources are different as they provide different points of view on Lim Yew Hock's government. Source A shows that Lim Yew Hock's government had been perceived negatively by the people, as seen from, "perceived by the chinese as running dogs' of the British". Whereas source B shows that Lim Yew Hock's government was well-liked by the people as seen from, "accepted policies which are right for Singapore".
Class: 2 Diligence
ReplyDeleteGroup Number: 2
Group Members' Names:
Gwee Ruo ann (10)
Li Jia Xin (15)
Pok Ci En (23)
Angelina Sam (27)
Tiong Zhi Yu (34)
Wong Xue Min (36)
Yeo Zhu Yinn(39)
Question: How different are the 2 sources?
Answer:
Source A is a view by an academic of Lim Yew Hock's government, but source B is a view by a fellow party member of Lim Yew Hock's government.
The sources are different because they provide conflicting points of view on Lim Yew Hock's government. Sources A shows that Lim Yew Hock did not run the government correctly, which can be seen from 'prepared to work with the British to achieve his constitutional goals,even if that involved the launch of a series of anti-communist purges'. However, Source B states that Lim Yew Hock ruled the government in the correct way as seen from' accepted policies which were right for Singapore'.
Class: 2 Hope
ReplyDeleteGroup Number: 5
Group members' Names:
Gabrielle Aw
Charlene Chua
Katrina Capel
Samantha Lim
Brenlyn Ng
Question:How is Source A different from Source B?
Answer:
Source A is a view by an academic of Lim Yew Hock's Government while source B is a view by a fellow party member of Lim Yew Hock's goverment.
Source A is different from source B because in source A, the people did not accept Lim Yew Hock's government which can be seen from' it ironically undermined the credibility of the Lim government which was percieved by the Chinese as the 'running dogs' of the British' whereas in source B, the people of Singapore accepted Lim Yew Hock's government which can be seen from '...under Lim Yew Hock we accepted policies which were right for Singapore,'
Class 2 Hope
ReplyDeleteGrop Number: 1
Group Members' Names:
Amanda Seh
Chan Yuan Ni
Francis Denise
Jean Ong
Tan Hai Yeng
Pamela Yap
Question: How similar is Source A to Source B?
Answer:
Both sources are similar because they are about the Lim Yew Hock government.
Both sources state how Lim Yew Hock ran the government. This is seen from Source A "launch of a series of anti-communist purges" and Source B which states that Lim Yew Hock gave "everyone the opportunity to take citizenship".
Both sources also state what Lim yew Hock did wrong. This is seen from Source A where it states "undermined the credibility of the Lim government" and Source B which tells us what Lim Yew Hock did was "wrong for the personal interests of the Labour Front leadership".